Friday, April 07, 2006

Hayek on IP

Friedrich von HayekA fascinating IP quote from that arch-communist, Friedrich von Hayek (via Le blog de Laurent Guerby):

The difference between these and other kinds of property rights is this: while ownership of material goods guides the user of scarce means to their most important uses, in the case of immaterial goods such as literary productions and technological inventions the ability to produce them is also limited, yet once they have come into existence, they can be indefinitely multiplied and can be made scarce only by law in order to create an inducement to produce such ideas. Yet it is not obvious that such forced scarcity is the most effective way to stimulate the human creative process. I doubt whether there exists a single great work of literature which we would not possess had the author been unable to obtain an exclusive copyright for it; it seems to me that the case for copyright must rest almost entirely on the circumstance that such exceedingly useful works as encyclopaedias, dictionaries, textbooks and other works of reference could not be produced if, once they existed, they could freely be reproduced.

Similarly, recurrent re-examinations of the problem have not demonstrated that the obtainability of patents of invention actually enhances the flow of new technical knowledge rather than leading to wasteful concentration of research on problems whose solution in the near future can be foreseen and where, in consequence of the law, anyone who hits upon a solution a moment before the next gains the right to its exclusive use for a prolonged period.

The Fatal Conceit: The Errors of Socialism, 1988 (p. 35)


Laurent GUERBY said...

I've always been surprised to find extreme support for IP amongst so called liberals, libertarians, hayekians and other "less state intervention".

Even on "Cafe Hayek" it is common to see applause for each new strenghtening of IP rights...

Russ Nelson said...

Huh? Citations please, Laurent. Intellectual property (patents and copyright, and to a lesser degree, trademarks) are theft from the commons. I know of no liberals, libertarians, or hayekians who support theft. So, please, until you can come up with citations, I call bullshit.